For Agencies Company sign in

Ranked on proof

Best debt collection agencies in Illinois

Ranked on what each agency can prove: licensed in Illinois, complaints answered on time, and how it protects clients' money and data. Rankings are never for sale.

Updated: November 21, 2026 · Kai Greenspan, Founding Editor

As of November 21, 2026, the best-proven debt collection agency in Illinois is MCCARTHY BURGESS & WOLFF INC, at Silver with 10 of 15 points. 18 agencies meet the bar for a number today. We checked all 196 Illinois agencies listed on this site against the Illinois register, public records and their own websites where we could read them, and rated 173 of them.
Number1

SilverOn the list because: Silver: 10 of 15 points

MCCARTHY BURGESS & WOLFF INC

  • Answered 312 of 312 complaints on time (CFPB, last three years)
  • CLLA Certified, on CLLA's public list
  • A client login on its own website
  • Data security: Stated on its own website

22 years on the Illinois registerNo regulator order found in the sources we check

Answer by answer

CFPB complaints on time
Data security
Client money
Reporting to clients
Compliance audit
View MCCARTHY BURGESS & WOLFF INC's full record

Today 18 agencies meet the bar for a number: Silver, or Bronze with a certification or a contract checked by an outside body. A list can hold fewer than ten; we never fill places to reach ten.

2
Radius Global Solutions On the list because: Silver: 10 of 15 points Answered 5,306 of 5,306 complaints on time (CFPB, last three years) · CLLA Certified, on CLLA's public list · RMAI Certified, on RMAI's public list
10 of 15 Silver
3
Caine & Weiner On the list because: Silver: 9 of 15 points CLLA Certified, on CLLA's public list · A client login on its own website
9 of 15 Silver
4
TRUEACCORD CORP. On the list because: Silver: 8 of 15 points A client login on its own website · RMAI Certified, on RMAI's public list
8 of 15 Silver
5
REMEX INC On the list because: Silver: 8 of 15 points Answered 80 of 80 complaints on time (CFPB, last three years) · A client login on its own website
8 of 15 Silver
6
NATIONAL COMMERCIAL SERVICES INC On the list because: Silver: 8 of 15 points Answered 85 of 85 complaints on time (CFPB, last three years) · A client login on its own website
8 of 15 Silver
7
VENGROFF WILLIAMS INC On the list because: Silver: 8 of 15 points Answered 33 of 33 complaints on time (CFPB, last three years) · A client login on its own website
8 of 15 Silver
8
C2C RESOURCES LLC On the list because: Silver: 6 of 12 points CLLA Certified, on CLLA's public list · A client login on its own website
6 of 12 Silver
9
KEARNS BRINEN & MONAGHAN INC On the list because: Silver: 6 of 12 points CLLA Certified, on CLLA's public list · A client login on its own website
6 of 12 Silver
10
GOLDMAN, WALKER & DIMARCO On the list because: Silver: 6 of 12 points CLLA Certified, on CLLA's public list · A client login on its own website
6 of 12 Silver
11
RELIANT CAPITAL SOLUTIONS LLC On the list because: Won a federal collection contract Answered 429 of 429 complaints on time (CFPB, last three years) · A client login on its own website
7 of 15 Bronze
12
STEEL RIVER SYSTEMS LLC On the list because: RMAI Certified, on RMAI's public list Debt buying: RMAI lists it as a certified debt buyer. It also collects for outside clients, in its own words. Answered 137 of 137 complaints on time (CFPB, last three years)
6 of 15 Bronze
13
STATE COLLECTION SERVICE INC On the list because: HFMA Peer Reviewed, on HFMA's public list Answered 140 of 140 complaints on time (CFPB, last three years) · A client login on its own website
6 of 15 Bronze
14
CREDIT CONTROL, LLC On the list because: RMAI Certified, on RMAI's public list Answered 3,202 of 3,202 complaints on time (CFPB, last three years)
6 of 15 Bronze
15
HALSTED FINANCIAL SERVICES LLC On the list because: RMAI Certified, on RMAI's public list
5 of 15 Bronze
16
NATIONAL RECOVERY SOLUTIONS LLC On the list because: RMAI Certified, on RMAI's public list
5 of 15 Bronze
17
LOCKHART MORRIS & MONTGOMERY INC On the list because: RMAI Certified, on RMAI's public list
5 of 15 Bronze
18
F H CANN & ASSOCIATES INC On the list because: Won a federal collection contract Answered 269 of 269 complaints on time (CFPB, last three years)
4 of 15 Bronze

Answers, left to right: CFPB complaints on time, Data security, Client money, Reporting to clients, Compliance audit. A filled bar is a point earned; three bars is the strongest answer.

Which other agencies are rated?

These agencies earned Bronze but have nothing checked by an outside body yet, so they are shown by level, in order, without a number. Each can be numbered by claiming its page and sending us a certification such as CLLA or RMAI, or a collection contract it won. Once we check it, the agency is numbered. Claiming never buys a place: only the proof counts.

Bronze 48 agencies
No level yet 95 agencies

21 more are not rated yet, because we could not read a website for them. Claiming a page and telling us yourself is the way to be rated.

2 more are not rated because their own website describes another kind of business, not a collection agency that takes clients.

Is this your agency? Claim your page, free for three months

Which agencies tied to debt buying are not numbered, and why?

A company that buys debt, or collects for an affiliate that owns the debt, is rated like any agency, and numbered only once we have read, in its own words, that it collects for outside clients. This one is not numbered until then. Claiming the page and showing us where it says so is the way on.

  • THE CADLE COMPANYBronze, 3 of 12 points. RMAI lists it as a certified debt buyer, and we have not yet read, in its own words, that it collects for outside clients.

Which agencies are held back, and why?

11 rated agencies are held back by their conduct record. An agency that answered under 95% of its CFPB complaints on time over three years (where it had 10 or more), or has a regulator order from the last five years that applies in Illinois, is not numbered. An order about licensing or paperwork applies only in the state that issued it. An order about how consumers were treated, or a federal order, applies in every state, unless it is a small penalty over a single consumer. Claiming a page does not change this. The facts are the regulators' own.

Which Illinois debt collectors can you trust, and how do we check?

5 questions, each worth up to three points. A proven answer beats a claim on a website. The level is the share of points earned.

Points are out of 15, or out of 12 for an agency we could not score on CFPB complaints (fewer than 10 in the last three years, or no CFPB company name we could match): that question is left out, never scored zero. The level is the share of points, so levels compare across both.

Bronze25%

A quarter of the points. Numbered on a list only where an outside body has checked the agency: a certification or a contract it won.

Silver50%

Half the points. Always numbered, unless held back by its conduct record.

Gold75%

Earned at least 75% of the points, and passed every conduct check we make. No agency on this list has met it yet.

Read the full methodology

Can an agency pay to be on this list?

No. Rankings are never for sale. Paying never moves an agency up. Some proof only the agency holds, like a security audit or its clients' views, so it gives us that proof through a claimed page, and we check it.

Common questions

Why is no agency at Gold?

Gold needs at least 75% of the points and every conduct check we make passed. No agency in Illinois has met it yet.

Why are there fewer than ten?

A number has to mean something. Only agencies at Silver, or Bronze agencies checked by an outside body, are numbered. We never fill places to reach ten. Every other agency with a level is shown below the list.

Why does price not count?

A lower fee is not a better agency. Fees depend on the debt and the work, so we never score them.

Is this your agency?

Claim your page and send us proof, such as a certification, a collection contract you won or a security audit report. Once we check it, it counts. Claiming never buys a place: only the proof counts.

See also: Best medical debt collection agencies in Illinois · Best commercial debt collection agencies in Illinois · All Illinois agencies